Oct 06

Soft and Tender Peanut Butter Cookies | Vegan and Gluten-Free

Soft and Tender Peanut Butter Cookies | Vegan and Gluten Free | blissfulbasil.com

Last week was a bit of a doozy. Lots going on at work and even more going on outside of work, and by the time I arrived home on Thursday night all I wanted for dinner was a handful of peanut butter cookies. A strange choice, I might add, considering we didn’t have any peanut butter cookies on hand but stranger cravings have happened. It’s a lovely thing to have a craving that is so easily accommodated for given the simplicity of ingredients needed. Had I been craving gold-flake encrusted peanut butter cookies, well then that might have posed a problem.

Over the last several weeks, I’ve been trying to make at least the majority of my weekday meals vegan. I’ve noticed that I feel more clear-headed and full of energy when I do, so I’ve worked to make it a habit. The weekends are still a time for falling off the vegan wagon, and if you witnessed my weekday breakfast trends you’d think I was a stockholder for Chobani. Such is life.

Peanut butter cookies are a cinch to make vegan, so I went ahead and made that a priority. As I got mixing, I figured why not up the health factor by allowing oat flour take the place of white flour. Now we’re talking vegan and gluten-free. Check and check. But of course the bottom line in any recipe is taste, and I promise you that these peanut butter cookies will knock the socks off of your cookie cravings. Like socks on the floor and cookie crumbs everywhere. I’ll let you gnaw on that image.

These cookies are the softest, densest, and most tender peanut butter cookies I’ve ever tasted. The use of brown sugar adds to their density and lends a warm, caramely layer to their peanut butter decadence. The path to making them vegan and gluten-free means that all that extra stuff that interferes (white flour, eggs, etc.) is cleared away and their true peanuty potential is reached rather effortlessly. They have this melt-in-your-mouth goodness about them, and they pair perfectly with a glass of plant-based milk.

Soft + Tender Peanut Butter Cookies | Vegan and Gluten Free | blissfulbasil.com

Soft + Tender Peanut Butter Cookies | Vegan and Gluten Free | blissfulbasil.com

Soft + Tender Peanut Butter Cookies | Vegan and Gluten Free | blissfulbasil.com

peanut butter cookie hearts

4.8 from 49 reviews
Soft + Tender Peanut Butter Cookies
 
Prep time
Cook time
Total time
 
The softest and most tender peanut butter cookies ever... and you'd never know they were vegan and gluten free unless you read this recipe! Peanut butter heaven wrapped up in pretty little crisscrossed packages. (tip: make your own oat flour by tossing rolled oats in a food processor and processing for 2-3 minutes until a fine "flour" has formed).
Author:
Recipe type: Dessert
Serves: 12-14
Ingredients
  • 1 cup peanut butter (you can also use ½ peanut butter and ½ almond butter)
  • 1 cup brown sugar
  • 2 teaspoons vanilla extract
  • ⅔ cup oat flour (use 1 cup if you prefer chewy cookies rather than tender cookies)
  • 1 tsp baking soda
  • ⅛ teaspoon salt
  • ¼ cup water (readers have also had success using ¼ cup almond milk)
Instructions
  1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit.
  2. In a large mixing bowl, cream together the peanut butter and brown sugar for 1 minute. Add in the vanilla extract and beat for another 30 seconds.
  3. In a separate mixing bowl, mix the dry ingredients together (oat flour, baking soda, and salt).
  4. While beating the peanut butter mixture, slowly add in the oat flour mixture and beat until a crumby dough forms. Add in the water and continue to beat until distributed. Do not over mix.
  5. Line two baking sheets with parchment paper.
  6. Roll the dough into balls (about 1½ - 2 tablespoons per cookie), drop on parchment paper, and flatten with a fork one way and then the other to create a crisscross pattern.
  7. Bake for 8-10 minutes or until just starting to turn golden on edges (they bake FAST so watch them carefully).
  8. Let cool completely.
  9. Store in an airtight plastic container to keep the cookies soft and chewy.
Notes
*Refined-Sugar-Free option: readers have had success using coconut sugar in place of the brown sugar.

 

Comments

  1. Those are making my mouth water…would be great with my coffee.

  2. Thank You!!! These were delicious :) I look forward to more vegan sweets from you!

  3. I made these the other day for a relative who is vegan and they were such a hit with everyone in the house. Thanks for posting this great recipe!

  4. Cassandra says:

    I made these yesterday, subbing crunchy natural (not no stir, it was what i had) almond butter, and coconut oil for the vegan spread. They turned out fantastic! chewy, tender, great flavor. my youngest is allergic to eggs, wheat, and dairy, and since I was making cookies for her sister I needed to make something for her. she is thrilled! Thank you for the great recipe!

    • What do you mean by vegan spread?

      • Hi Shelley, thanks for pointing that out in this comment! There isn’t any vegan spread, such as Earth Balance, in this recipe so that comment must be an error or a comment that should have landed on another recipe. Just follow the recipe exactly as posted :)

        • I think she meant that because she used “stir peanut butter” instead of no stir, she had to adapt her peanut butter (which was just crushed peanuts) into a nut butter blend with an oil in it. Often no stir peanut butters contain oils, sugar, and salt.

  5. Do you have any suggestions for baking soda and baking powder? That are vegan

  6. I have pb that’s close to expiration (we stocked up!), so I looked up a vegan cookie recipe. I’m about to try these. I’ll let you know how they taste with my glass of “milk”.

  7. Just finished making these. Note: I used my regular All-Purpose flour, but this recipe made some soft, delicious cookies! I’m excited to share them with husband. He loves peanut butter! Thanks!

    • I’m so glad you’re enjoying them and it’s helpful to know that they’re still just as tasty with all purpose flour! Thanks for the update!

  8. Cassandra says:

    I just made these and they were so delicious! I split the brown sugar with maple sugar (my husband’s family is from NH, so there are a lot of maple products in the house!!) and it gave the cookies a wonderful maple flavor! I used regular all-purpose flour since that is all I had- for my variation I had to bake them a little bit longer, but they still came out chewy and delicious! I’m vegan, but my husband and his family are not; this sweet treat was a hit with everyone and they seemed very surprised that a vegan diet can taste so wonderful! Thanks so much for the recipe!!!

    • Hi Cassandra! Thanks for trying out the recipe and for commenting with how the adjustments worked out for you! I will have to make these with maple sugar next time — that sounds so delicious. I’m so glad that these cookies impressed non-vegans! Always an exciting moment when you can surprise people with how delicious vegan food can be :)

      • Cassandra says:

        Ashley! I tried to give you five stars, but my iPhone wouldn’t let me… but just know it is a 5-star recipe! The whole batch is already gone and my husband is begging me to make more :)

        • Oh my gosh, you’re so sweet! Thanks for commenting back with your 5-star rating! Also, love when the husbands beg for vegan food — it’s so cute, isn’t it?

  9. This is the perfect peanut butter cookie recipe!! They are just the texture and flavor I was looking for. Plus, they couldn’t have been easier to make. As a vegetarian making the transition to a vegan lifestyle, I am always looking for new tasty recipes to add to my recipe box, and this is a keeper. I did have to make one adjustment because I didn’t have enough creamy peanut butter, so I used 1/2 cup creamy and 1/2 cup crunchy. I have to say, I loved the added texture of the crunch! As another commenter said, they took a little longer to bake, about 10 minutes for me. My boyfriend tried these not knowing they were vegan and raved about how good they were. When I told him they were vegan, he said, “You tricked me!” Keep the great recipes coming!

    • Hi Becky! Umm, thank you for the amazingly sweet words! I need to try this creamy-crunchy pb combo the next time I make these cookies. Isn’t it the best when our loved ones unknowingly eat vegan foods and melt over their deliciousness?! I “trick” my husband all the time, too! Also, thank you for noting that the baking time was closer to 10 minutes — I will update the recipe to reflect the variance in baking times. I’m quickly learning that the oven in our new-ish home is like a mini inferno, and it seems to bake EVERYTHING quicker than expected!

  10. These look amazing, but do you think I could sub the peanut butter with Sunbutter?

    • Yes, I definitely think that would work! You might have to add a bit more oat flour if the sunbutter is runny but otherwise I think it should sub really well. Please let me know how it goes!

  11. I made these for my kids {and hubs} last night and they LOVED them!! We will def be making them again! I love your photography too btw. I also only had pb on hand that separates, and they still turned out amazing! Thanks for blogging this recipe and taking the time to stage them so lovely. :)

    • Hi Talia! Thanks for reporting back with kind words and helpful substitution hints! I’m glad to know that they do turn out with pb that separates, and I will add a note into the recipe. Also, thank you for the sweet compliments on the photos! It’s definitely the part of being a food blogger that challenges me the most, so your words mean a lot to me :)

  12. This recipe is great! Super easy to make and super tasty!! I’m allergic to peanuts so I subbed the peanut butter with a toasted soy spread called wow butter (tastes just like peanut butter). They were amazing!!!

  13. do you have to use oat flour? or can you use regular, and make it non gluten free, but still vegan

  14. Hello, Ashley. I don’t have brown sugar so can I make them with honey??

    • Hi Donika, I’m not sure how they’ll turn out with honey as I haven’t tried substituting with it but please let me know how it goes/went if you try it!

  15. This recipe was great! Just what I was looking for. Thank you.

  16. These were fabulous!!! I am not vegan, but have discovered the joys of vegan baking. At first glance, I wondered how cookies without the usual butter/egg combination would taste, but these are absolutely delicious and so easy to make. I used my Nutribullet to make oat flour – quick and easy!

    • Hi Pam! I’m so happy to hear that you enjoyed them so much! Great tip to make the oat flour in a Nutribullet. Thanks for sharing!

  17. Roslynne Crawford says:

    These cookies are awesome! Next time, I am going to put the cookies in the freezer for 30 mins or so to reduce them spreading out. Mine were a bit thin. Thanks, Ashley. I am a new vegan so it’s a pleasure to read your blog and try out some delicious recipes.

    • I’m so glad you enjoyed them and thank you for the feedback! Great idea about freezing the dough prior to baking, as they can spread out a bit. I might have to add that into the recipe notes!

  18. SOOOO GOOD! I added coconut oil in, and subbed the water with almond milk. BEST VEGAN COOKIES I HAVE FOUND TO DATE! Thank you so much for sharing it!

    • You’re making me blush! Thank you so much for the amazing cookie compliments, Carly (try saying that 10 times fast). Can I ask how much coconut oil you added? Just asking in case other readers want to make that addition since coconut oil has so many awesome health benefits. Thanks for reading, baking, and commenting!

  19. I made these tonight with maple syrup in place of the sugar. I was worried they’d be a bit too soft as the batter was quite runnuly but they turned out fantastic! I actually forgot about them and they didn’t over cook.

  20. I am not much of a baker, but I had a huge craving for (vegan, gluten-free) peanut butter cookies last night. After searching through recipes that had ingredients I didn’t care for, or long lists of various flours and binders, I found yours and thought it looked like something I could handle. I blended my own oat flour, leaving just a few larger flakes intact and used a combo of almond butter and peanut butter (because I didn’t have a full cup of pb). The cookies were fantastic! Exactly what I wanted – peanutty, not too sweet, chewy and a little salty. This morning, I ate one with my coffee and it had become satisfyingly crunchy around the edges and maintained a really good chewiness in the centre. Thank you, thank you! This may be my go-to recipe from now on.

    • I’m so glad you enjoyed them, Mishka! Thank you for sharing your thoughts on them — you’ve inspired me to try these with my morning coffee!

  21. Alba Marina says:

    Hey! I was wondering if I could use baking powder instead of baking soda? Thanks!

    • Hi Alba! I’ve never tried substituting baking powder for baking soda in this recipe, so I can’t vouch for it having the same results. However, usually you need 2-3 times the amount in order to sub baking powder for baking soda, but it can affect the flavor. If you try it, please comment and let me know how it works! Good luck!

  22. Not sure how many vegans are going to want to dip their cookies in a cold glass of milk… but this recipe looks great!

    • Hi Natalie! Thanks for the sweet words! By “milk” I mean plant-based milk (almond, cashew, coconut, etc) — there is an entire world of non-dairy milk options :)

  23. this recipe is the BOMB! Eight cookies given to me as a take home treat for the hubby ( I am not a cookie kinda person) , and I nipped the corner of one for a quick lil taste… eight cookies later… I am a convert. And the hubby will just have to wait until i make them myself… FIVE STARS of perfect addiction… :)

    • What an awesome compliment — thank you!! I feel honored that this recipe converted a non-cookie person! :)

  24. These were really delicious. Instead of water I used chocolate almond milk. They were sooo good.

    • What a fabulous idea to use chocolate almond milk! Thanks for the wonderful idea, and so glad you enjoyed the cookies!

  25. I just made these and they were amazing. I was really craving something sweet for dessert and it was really easy I already had all the ingredients. It’s so nice to find eggless recipes. Thank you!

  26. Best Peanut butter cookies ever! something so delish! Simple and quick. I am eatting too much though lol, also because of this recipe, I’m making my own oat flour which u drop your oats in a blender or proceesor and done! going to try the other recipesssss. You go girl!

  27. These cookies were amazing!!!! Followed the recipe exactly. Made my own oat flour out of oats like the notes said. Easy! My non vegan fiancé is on his 4th cookie. My stupid iPhone won’t let me rate w the stars but 5stars!!!!

  28. Thank you so much for this recipe, I can’t wait to try it!

    Please note that BROWN SUGAR IS NOT ALWAYS VEGAN as the processing of the sugar uses Bone Char from cow bones.

    • Hi Andrea! Thanks for the insight on brown sugar — I had no idea! I just checked on the one that I use (Trader Joe’s Organic Brown Sugar), and it is vegan. Thank goodness!

  29. Hi Ashley,
    I stumbled across your recipe and made them as fast as I could gather up the ingredients!!! I used 1/4 teaspoon of kosher salt in lieu of the 1/8 teaspoon of regular salt and in my food processor I pulsed my own oat flour using gf whole oats. I went with your readers suggestion and used almond milk instead of water. Fan-friggin’-tastic peanut butter cookies!!! THANKS for sharing this recipe and I hope my readers love them as much as I do!!!

  30. PS….I went with the full cup of oat flour too!!!

  31. YUMMMMY! These are so so darn good! I had no idea what to expect because of no butter or anything but they are the BOMB! I just made myself sick though, they are very rich so please ladies no eating the whole batch :D

  32. Made these with my 2 year old son yesterday and they were amazing! Thanks! How can I share this recipe on my Twitter?

    • Hi Julie! I’m so glad you enjoyed the peanut butter cookies! You can share the recipe on Twitter by linking directly to the post. Thanks for checking and for your lovely feedback!

  33. Woweeeeeee says:

    These are amazing!!!!! Best peanut butter cookie recipe I have ever tried.

  34. Hello Ashley,

    This recipe is simply amazing! I add chocolate chips to my cookies to make it even more mouth watering. I hope that is okay that I made a printable of this recipe, it was just so delicious!

    Thanks for sharing!

    Janelle

    • Hi Janelle! I’m so glad you’re enjoying the recipe! Great idea adding in chocolate chips! Sharing the recipe is fine as long as you link back to both my homepage and the original recipe post within the printable. Thanks for checking!

  35. I made these this morning for a friends birthday who is not Vegan or GF. I looked all over the internet for a good pb cookie recipe that didn’t have rice flour but oat flour – as my family is gluten free; but my non GF friends can taste the rice flour I put in things. This was IT!! All I can say is that these are AWESOME! The only thing I would change next time I made them would be a little more peanut butter, but I really like Peanut butter. I also added a tsp of Baking powder to help the cookie not spread. I have found with GF baking that it helps. These were great, because it was just simple ingredients, nothing weird; no special mixing, basic stuff. you would never know these were without the eggs and butter. Love them! Seriously if anyone has doubts, DONT! Just go for it, you’ll be glad you did!

    • Hi Eileen! Thanks so much for commenting with your feedback! I’m so glad you enjoyed the cookies so much. It makes me so happy to hear about people sharing them with friends and family and having positive results! That is a great tip about adding baking powder — I never would have thought to do add it in to prevent the cookies from spreading. I’ll absolutely try it the next time I make them! Thanks again for your kind words!

  36. I have made these twice with good results. To jazz them up a little I added a few handfulls of trail mix & granola, plus a little cinnamon. They seem to be pretty foolproof (I don’t even measure, just eyeball & dump everything in the bowl). :)

    • Umm, genius idea to add trail mix, granola and cinnamon; that sounds amazing! Glad you’re enjoying the recipe, Autumn!

  37. hi, can u add a photo of the dough after adding the water?
    it looks very watery and stickey to me,,
    tnx

    • Hi Eliko! I can add a photo of the dough the next time I make these; however, the dough should not be watery after adding the 1/4 cup of water or almond milk. It should add just enough moisture to get the dough to hold together nicely so that you can form the cookies for baking. What kind of peanut butter did you use?

      • tnx :)
        actually after 5 minutes the dough was ok to work with.but when i tryed to make the cross pattern the fork just sticked to the dough .
        after 10 minutes in the oven the cookies spreaded ALL over the baking sheets – is it ok?
        i added the photo:
        http://i58.tinypic.com/oftt21.jpg

        • Hmm, it does sound like the dough was a bit too wet and the cookies typically don’t spread out like that; however, they should still taste delicious and hold up fine. You can try chilling the dough for 30 minutes or more before baking next time or add in a touch more oat flour if you want to reduce the spreading.

  38. Oh. My. God. I’ve been making peanut butter cookies since I was a kid, and these are the best!

    I was low on peanut butter, so I just made a 1/2 batch–it worked perfectly. I used 1/2 cup of oat flour for the 1/2 batch, and coconut milk instead of water. The perfect cookie for a rainy night.

    • Thanks, Traci! I’m so glad you’re enjoying the cookies so much! Also, thank you for the including the measurements you used to cut the recipe in half; it’s always great to know what works! I think I need to start making half batches, too :)

  39. nom nom de nom says:

    I think the texture would be something like Shortbread, especially if you use some cornstarch in place of about 1/4 cup oat flour.

  40. These biscuits are fantastic. I am gluten and dairy intolerant so finding yummy things to eat can be a challenge. So easy to make, thank you

  41. I made these with soynut butter since the kids’ schools are nut free… Delicious!!! Thanks:)

    • Hi Shayna! I’m so happy to hear they worked with soynut butter. Thanks for sharing your modification!

  42. wow jeez these are good!! thank you!! :)

  43. Ashley C. says:

    These are oh so delicious! Loving each bite! Simply beautiful

  44. YUM! Thank you for this recipe! Delicious! and my PB Cookie fans didn’t even know they were vegan!

    • You’re welcome, Renee! I’m so glad to hear that everyone enjoyed the cookies! Always a good sign when no one knows they’re vegan :)

  45. Just made these and my husband who’s not vegan LOVED them, he thought they were “even better than the non vegan”. I used all purpose flour since it was what I had and left them in the oven for double the time, they are delicious. Thank you !

    • Hi Raquel! I’m so happy to hear that you and your husband loved the cookies! What a great compliment that he thought they were better than the “non-vegan” kind :) Thanks for taking the time to report back and provide the notes on your adjustments with all purpose flour.

  46. Hi! I was looking for a recipe with oat flour and natural peanut butter, and here they are! Thanks! Yes, I used the kind of peanut butter you have to stir, and it was so hard, I emptied the entire new jar into my food processor, whirred it smooth, and scraped the unused part right back into the jar! The recipe worked great! I used vanilla almond milk, and made the cookies not as flat. They are beautiful, tender, and delish! And I fell, almost guilt-free! Win-win! SO glad I found your blog!

    • Hi Nancy! Thanks for your sweet words and for your tips about using the kind of peanut butter you have to stir; I’m so happy to hear it worked out with it. Great idea to throw it in the food processor first to completely incorporate the oil. I’m SO glad you found Blissful Basil, too! :)

  47. Marlo Saul says:

    Hi Ashley! Today is my first day finding your blog and I’m so glad that I did! I had a crazy PB cookie craving hit and these little gems were put to the test! I’m a chewy cookie girl so I went for the whole cup of flour. I also subbed a homemade almond/walnut butter for the pb and coconut palm sugar for the brown sugar and I added Enjoy mini chocolate chips. My batch was too loose to press with a fork so I thought they might be a flop but they turned out AMAZING! I usually roll half of my batter in plastic wrap and refrigerate so I can slice a couple singles to bake after my kids go to sleep, this recipe will be perfect for that! I’m keeping this recipe in my arsenal! Thanks so much!

    • Hi, Marlo! I’m so glad that you found Blissful Basil and had a chance to make these cookies and enjoyed them! Thank you for outlining your substitutions; it’s always wonderful to hear that the cookies turn out even with adjustments. I definitely need to try adding in mini chocolate chips; peanut butter + chocolate = the best!

  48. Jessica I. says:

    Made these for the second time tonight and once again they are dee-licious! Both times I made the oat flour with my Nutribullet and I used natural peanut butter which does separate but they were perfect! The first time I made them tender and the second time I went for chewy; either/or is great. I love how quick and easy these are to make; this is officially my go-to peanut butter cookie recipe! Thanks for this!

    • Thanks so much for commenting with your feedback, Jessica! I’m so glad you’ve enjoyed the cookies both ways, and what a great idea to process the oat flour in a Nutribullet. I’ll definitely have to try that the next time I make them :)

  49. Wow, just wanted to say thanks so much for sharing this recipe, these cookies are amazing! I LOVE that all of the ingredients are healthy too, making them pretty guilt-free in my books. It can be tough to find healthy-but-delicious sweet vegan recipes (that aren’t a raw vegan tart!). So good to see a recipe without vegan spread or general flour (I sometimes don’t even feel that comfortable using wholemeal flour, to be honest).

    I used coconut sugar and natural peanut butter and it was great. Also sneaked in some vegan sugar free dark choc chips and some ripe banana chunks! Super duper delicious. Also, I love the oat flour. These cookies are actually really filling and satisfying compared to cookies that call for normal flour – I think this is due to the oat flour (and the peanut butter, of course!). So good.

    Thanks again! It’s people like you who are making the vegan world more friendly and accessible, gotta love that!

    With love from Australia :)

    • Alex! Thanks for taking the time to write such a long, thoughtful, and sweet comment. I really appreciate the feedback, and I’m so glad you enjoyed the cookies. Adding chocolate and peanut butter chunks sounds like the best idea ever; I will have to try that the next time I make these. I’ll make a note in the recipe that coconut sugar can be used in place of brown sugar, so thank you for noting that substitution!

  50. Anneli Olila says:

    WAY too sweet. Offensively sweet. Too bad.

    • Hi Anneli, I’m sorry that you felt that these were too sweet! I’ve never heard that complaint about these cookies before, but you can always cut back on the brown sugar or use coconut sugar instead.

  51. Any suggestion to replace oat flour, have a son , no gluten,dairy,egg or oats it mimics gluten in the body.
    Baking without eggs is a challenge for myself, love to hear suggestions
    Thank you

    • Hi there! Can your son have buckwheat? If so, try using raw buckwheat groats and grind them into a fine flour in the food processor. It’s a simple swap for the oat flour and works well for those with allergies since it’s a seed. You may need to add in a bit more water because it can be more absorbent than oat flour. I’d love to hear how they turn out for you.

      As for baking without eggs, there are a variety of substitutes depending on what you’re making. Here is a helpful post that provides allergen-friendly baking substitutes from the amazing vegan, gluten-free blog Fork and Beans: http://www.forkandbeans.com/2013/11/22/guide-egg-substitutions/

  52. I JUST made this with almond milk instead of water, and I made my own oat flour out of gluten free old fashioned oats. THESE ARE AMAZING.

    • Hi, Emily! Thank you for taking the time to comment with your feedback and adjustments. I’m so happy to hear that you’re enjoying the recipe!

  53. I just pulled a batch out of the oven, I can’t wait for them to cool! I found that I didn’t have enough peanut butter or almond butter (even combined) so I added coconut oil since I saw another reader was using very whole and natural nut butter (mine is, too) and added coconut oil to hers. I was worried that I would have to add too much oil to make it a cup, since it was only about half a cup of nut butters, but I think the recipe turned out alright. I used my own gf flour blend (one part each of coconut flour, oat flour, brown rice flour, and arrowroot powder) and added about 1/4 cup of cocoa powder to the recipe, too. I’m very excited to taste them, they look perfect!! Thank you for posting such a simple recipe!

    • Hi Jane!Thank you for sharing all of your substitutions! The cocoa powder addition sounds especially delicious. I hope they turned out well with the adjustments. Enjoy, and you’re welcome :)

  54. Maria Taylor says:

    Thank You. This is a great recipe. I did not have the oat flour but I did blend with the blender some Instant oat meal I did 1 cup and almost a half to make sure I was able to get a cup (the recipe explains you can use 1 cup if you want them to be chewy instead of tender). Wonderful choice because I love extra soft fall apart cookies. I baked them a few minutes longer because ovens vary in temperature and mine were still too soft. I also used jar creamy peanut butter. It worked well for me. I will try it with the recommended one as soon as I get it because this was greeaaat even with the modifications so I am 100% sure it will be even better with the recommended items. Thank you so much my boys loved these cookies. You are great and so is the recipe. : )

  55. My favorite peanut butter cookies ever! They are so soft and pillowy! I’ve made these three times now and love them more each time :)

  56. These are delicious! I erred on the side of underbaking them since they continue to bake for a bit after taking out of the oven. I baked at 350 for about 8 min and they are perfect…slightly browned and crispy on the edges, chew in the center. My husband, who is a peanut butter cookie fanatic, loves these, and didn’t notice they are gluten and egg free. I used rice milk in place of the water and added a smidge more peanut butter (maybe 1 T). Thank you for posting this recipe, my egg-free kids appreciate it!

    • You’re welcome! I’m so happy that you and your family enjoyed them so much. Thanks for taking the time to comment with your feedback and adjustments!

  57. These are delicious!!!! My family loves them! I had to recently give up eggs, I was sad but thanks to great recipes like this one I am still baking away! I have to omit the vanilla but wish I could keep it. I am sure it would be the icing on the cake :)

    • I’m so happy to hear that you’re loving the pb cookies, Joanne! I’m sure it’s been a tricky adjustment to get used to baking without eggs and vanilla, but I’m glad this recipe has helped prove that you can still create delicious treats. Thanks so much for taking the time to comment with your results :)

  58. Hey.

    I’m about to try making these for a freind, just wondering does it matter whether light brown or dark brown sugar is used? :)

    :)

  59. Loved these. Why would you waste eggs these are so amazing as it. Not a vegan, so no restrictions, but huge fan. I am a former gourmet buyer a for a baked goods co…so ive have had my share..these are great. I added a spice called baking spice by penzys, a bit like allspice or pumpkin pie spice with cardamon

    • Hi, Michelle! I’m so glad that you loved the cookies. Penzys is my absolute favorite brand of spices, but I have yet to try Baking Spice. That sounds amazing though, and I bet it really added oomph to the flavor in these cookies. Thanks for the creative twist!

  60. Yummmmm! So tasty. I only have natural peanut butter so I used a cup of that and added a couple tbsp of margarine to get a smooth consistency. I used the full cup of oat flour for a chewy cookie and also subbed a chia egg (1 tbsp chia seeds with 3 tbsps water) for the plain water as I wanted to be sure they wouldn’t crumble apart. They turned out wonderful, I have eaten at least 4 since they came out of the oven earlier today.

  61. Just tried these with my family; they were a huge hit! And we happened to have everything on-hand, thankfully!
    I wrote about them on my blog and linked back to your blog. :)

    We’ll definitely be making these often. Uh oh! Hahaha. Have a good day!

    • Thanks for the feedback and link back to my blog, Lauren! I’m so glad you and your family enjoyed the cookies. I seem to ALWAYS have every ingredient on hand for these, which is both the best thing ever and a dangerous thing. My husband and I can tear through an entire batch in just a few days :)

  62. I made these yesterday for family, and they were perfect! Such a simple and easy recipe. I used whole wheat flour instead of oat. I hope you dont mind if I share the recipe on my blog?

    • Hi Shashika! I’m so glad you enjoyed these cookies! You can share the recipe, just be sure to change the title of it (so that it doesn’t conflict with search results) and link back to my original post. Thank you!

  63. These turned out awesome! I wish I had measured everything because I may not be able to do it again because I didn’t have any peanut butter, so I roasted a pie plate of peanuts then processed them into peanut butter with about a tbsp of coconut oil and some salt. It turned out a bit runny for peanut butter. Then I had only 1/2 cup of brown panela sugar, so I added a bit of maple syrup (maybe 2 tbsp?). I processed all of this and it was quite crumbly. I ground up oatmeal to make about 3/4 cup. I added 1 tsp of baking soda and no salt because I oversalted the peanut butter. I put everything into a bowl and stirred by hand, adding 1/4 cup water. This was the perfect consistency and made perfect balls that weren’t sticky and didn’t fall apart. I added some chocolate chips, too. Baked at 350 and these came out as the most perfect and delicious cookies I have ever made. Thank you so much for this recipe! If I could give it more stars I would!

    • I also used vanilla and flattened the balls with a fork, of course!

    • Marilyn! Thank you so much for the awesome and detailed feedback/adjustments! I love that you made homemade peanut butter — so impressive and I bet that added such a rich flavor. Great idea to add in chocolate chips, too!

  64. I should really stress that I have been baking since I was a kid and I have never had such perfect cookies turn out before.

  65. The cookies are great…..my husband has pancrititis and he is limited on normal ingredients. Thanks for a wonderful recipe

  66. These were fantastic! I made a coupe changes to adjust to my diet, however. I am on a no-auger-added diet which basically means you don’t add any kind of sweetener to anything (the thought is that the fiber in fruit and other sweet produce regulates your blood sugar). For this recipe, I substituted the Brown Sugar requirement for 1.25 cups of chopped dates. I blended the chopped dates, peanut butter, and almond milk together in a food processor until a fairly creamy consistency (dates are pretty hard to liquefy). I then used this mixture in place of the Sugar & Peanut butter requirements of the recipe. I also added raisins to the tops of the cookies for a healthier appearance. I don’t eat a lot of sweet things, but if I could choose anything for dessert, this would be it. Thanks!

    • Hi, Jack! Thanks so much for the feedback and awesome substitution notes. I love that you tried this with dates and that it worked out so well! I’ve substituted coconut sugar before, but never thought to use dates — I can’t wait to try it. Also love the idea of adding raisins to the top. PB and raisins are such a solid combination. So glad you enjoyed this recipe!

  67. I’m making two big batches of these today for friends. This is about the fourth time I’ve made them, last time I added trader Joe’s semi sweet chocolate chips. They turned out delicious and I always use tjs peanut butter and they come out great. Doing one with crunchy one with creamy & chocolate chips today. I love these because they are vegan but also so easy and everyone loves them, vegan or not.

    • So happy to hear you’re enjoying these so much, Rheanna! I seriously need to try adding chocolate chips, as I’ve heard so many good things about that addition. Love the crunchy/creamy variations, too! I bet crunchy would be delicious. Thanks so much for taking the time to share your thoughts!

  68. jeff ruth says:

    Great cookies!!! Minor changes to the original recipe, however, in that I used stir (100% peanuts) peanut butter and for liquid I used a quarter cup blend of water and maple syrup. I am Canadian, maple syrup belongs in everything eaten! They turned out absolutely delicious!!!

    • Thanks, Jeff! And I love the idea of adding maple syrup. Although I’m not Canadian, I can get on-board with adding maple syrup to just about anything. It’s seriously the best and lends such a rich, caramel flavor unlike anything else. Thanks for taking the time to share your substitutions and kind words!

  69. No-stir peanut butter has palm oil in it which is a terrible thing to support.

    • Hi, Claire. I’ll be completely honest: when I wrote this recipe a year and a half ago, I didn’t know about all of the issues with palm oil. That being said, I first learned about the issues about 10 months ago and should have updated the recipe to reflect this knowledge. It’s updated now. Thank you for your input.

      • Awesome! Thank you so much for updating your recipe to not include palm oil. It takes two seconds to stir peanut butter and saves the orangutans! :)

  70. The taste was absolutely fantastic! However, the texture was terrible for me :( I put them in the oven for about 12 minutes and decided to get them out because they were already past-golden, but they were still incredibly soft…the texture resembled the batter, actually.
    I read someone put them in the fridge for a while, so I’ll try them again doing that extra step
    Thanks so much for the wonderful recipe, I was *dying* for some PB cookies!

    • Hi, Naty! I’m glad you enjoyed the taste but so sorry that the texture was off for you. Did you let them cool completely before moving them? They are more delicate cookies, but the texture shouldn’t resemble the dough after baking. Sometimes variations in the thickness of peanut butter can affect the texture. I would definitely try refrigerating the dough or adding more oat flour. I hope this helps, and I’d love to know how they turn out the second time around!

  71. Wowowowoowow!! So good, I had to go through the effort of leaving a comment!! I am so unimpressed by any baked vegan dessert I ever had but THIS. WOW! SO good!! I added a few more tablespoons of flour because it looked too wet and it was just perfect. Thank you so much.

  72. could you use cocnut milk instead of almoind milk, would it still work the same in the recipe?

    • Hi, Sandra! I haven’t tried it myself, but it should work just fine as long as the thickness of the coconut milk is similar to almond milk. I’d love to know how it goes!

  73. I made the cookies and they are great. I find it very ironic however, that you make it a point to make them animal -free and animal testing free, yet you encourage readers to enjoy the cookies with a cold glass of milk. You should specify that it should be soy or almond milk to be totally animal cruelty concious. Just my comments anyway.

    • Hi, Tracy! I’m happy to hear that you enjoyed the cookies, and I appreciate your input on specifying a plant-based milk rather than just stating “milk”. I hadn’t yet shifted to veganism at the time when I wrote this post in 2013, so I wasn’t as sensitive as I now am. So, although I wrote “milk” in this post with plant-based milk in mind, I didn’t think to clarify. I’ll make the clarification now though. Thanks for catching this and for commenting!

  74. These are really delicious! I’ve made them twice, once with oat flour and once with AP. Both times they needed to be in the oven for more than 10 minutes (maybe 15?…not sure if it has something to do with me using crunchy PB instead of creamy). Nonetheless, they were really delish, and I’m just in love with how easy it is to put everything together! Thank you so much for the recipe!

Trackbacks

  1. […] cookies. I highly suggest you check her page out of you get a chance or two. Check out the recipe here (I followed it to the T, well, give or take the parchment paper bit…but I’m getting […]

  2. […] Butter cookies for our knitting group’s Gluten-Free Cookie exchange. I used this recipe form Blissful Basil. They turned out wonderful, if I do say so myself. They reminded me of the Pirate cookies Grandmas […]

  3. […] recipe makes it to your kitchen and does the thanking for me. Since you all seem to enjoy these Vegan + Gluten-Free Peanut Butter Cookies so much, I thought I would do a no-bake bark that incorporated much of their peanut buttery […]

  4. […] Chocolate Peanut Butter Banana Milk Shake – Seriously, enough said. Am I on a comfort food bender or what?!! […]

  5. […] to the following conclusions: extreme winter weather 1) increases soup consumption, 2) increases peanut butter cookie consumption, 3) increases clumsiness on ice patches, and 4) decreases likelihood of showering on […]

  6. […] why! It was a case of momentary cookie recipe hoarding, and it just wasn’t right. Since these peanut butter cookies have been a huge and humbling hit, I wanted to create a raw nut butter cookie with similar […]

  7. […] found this recipe here http://blissfulbasil.com/2013/10/06/soft-and-tender-peanut-butter-cookies-vegan-and-gluten-free/ and I think it’s a wonderful recipe. I haven’t tried it yet, but will use honey […]

  8. […] Butter Cookies: Just fucking classic. Here’s a great vegan/gluten free recipe as […]

  9. […] butter and chocolate! So you can imagine my excitement when I tested out this amazing recipe from Blissful Basil. This is definitely the best PB cookie I have ever made from scratch. The only thing I did […]

  10. […] Best vegan and gluten-free peanut butter cookies ever. I stumbled on this recipe at Blissful Basil a few weeks ago, and I’ve made the cookies twice […]

  11. […] adapted this peanut butter cookie recipe from Blissful Basil.  I just loved that it was both vegan and gluten free, so all my vegan friends […]

  12. […] Soft and Tender Peanut Butter Cookies | Vegan and Gluten-Free – The softest and most tender peanut butter cookies ever… and you’d never know they were vegan and gluten free unless you read this recipe! Peanut butter heaven …… […]

  13. […] always find myself in the mood for cookies. Last night was no different, so I found this recipe for ‘Soft and Tender Peanut Butter Cookies’ by Blissful Basil online and threw some together. Vegan and gluten free, these were exactly what I […]

  14. […] Adapted from: Ashley. blissfulbasil.com […]

  15. […] Vegan Gluten-free Peanut Butter cookies from Blissful […]

  16. […] This peanut butter cookie recipe was from the blog Blissful Basil which I want to explore a little more in my spare time (right!).  I think I made only one change which was to slightly increase the amount of salt (I like my salt!) […]

  17. […] Adapted from Blissful Basil’s peanut butter cookie recipe […]

Speak Your Mind

*

Rate this recipe: